10 Alive: If we assume Frosty (Friendly Neighbour) + the 2 Mason's can't be Mafia That leaves: Me (Homer) Town JOAT - confirmed role cop ability (Burg) Papa F (Officer Eddie) 2 shot role cop - Confirmed role cop ability (Adz) Lugna R (Rainer) Day Vig - Confirmed (Shot Guyett + Garrincha) Josh (Dr Nick) Doctor - Not confirmed, but no counter claim and was seen visiting Jason. (Expected Doctor target) Sgt (Roy) VT - Late entry into game. Adz (Krusty) Double Voter - Ability confirmed but no pro town play Scunny (Milhouse) Hider - Not proven For me, Josh and Papa I'm happy with. I don't think a scum role cop uses it on Adz Night 1 and Josh hasn't been counter claimed. Lugna appears town, but I'm not ruling out a scum vig that loses his ability when he kills town. I've proven my role, and think I may have stopped the night kill last night but I will let others decide on me. That leaves Sgt, Adz or Scunny for the final Mafia.
huh. no marge in game set up? Ive got this as kind of character linkages. Cops Jason Chief Wiggum, Clumsy Town Cop Papa Francesco Claim cop Eddie (what were the two results given) Masons BoroBob claims Stonecutter mason, specifically lenny David other mason, told to us by bob SK: Guyett Skeleton wille. Serial killer (clear loaner) Mafia Burg FAT TONY - GODFATHER TLC Mr Burns mafia poisoner Richard Nelson Muntz Mafia strong man Doctors Garrincha Dr Hibbert town poison doctor JoshBCFC Claim dr nick Doctor Simpons family: RedDevil19 Homer simpson jack of all trades Mr Sheen Bart simpson Town Paranoid wathcer. Hashtag55 Lisa simpson Innocent child/busybody (all have inv possibilities) Rest of cast: Lunga Rambler Rainer wolf castle Town Vigilante Sme Ol Gil town back up StillHurts31 Otto - town Bus driver ScunnyMadAndy Milhouse -hider Adz Claims Krusty the clown and doube voting. Frosty sending packages ned flanders Zydus Waylon Smithers, Town Easily Convinced Miller Sgt Serious Rob, Vanilla Surely @David and @borobob realise that stone cutters were not good guys. we need some help here. @Papa, you said you got Bobs role. who else did you get again?
I actually don't hate this theory. I think based on actual play in the game as well Adz is much more deserving to be lynched than Scunny.
We’ve had very little chat so far. I’m Carl Carlson Town Stonecutter (Mason). Our chat is day chat we were not town confirmed to each other in the role card or opening messages
Just seems extremely odd that Adz kept it hidden so long - also during that time we had three scum wagons, two of which were caught red handed. No harm in Adz putting down a double vote on Burg or Richard. …only draw back to this one is Papa Fs investigation
One thing that does concern me a little: Andy (Innocent Child) Frosty (Friendly Neighbour) Borobob (Mason) David (Mason) Seems like a lot of non mafia confirmed roles.
I also can’t see why Masons wouldn’t be Town confirmed. Is there something else at play or is purely to not rule out they were the SK who we know was Guyett… Also not convinced Milhouse fits as a hider either.
Guyett was killed so long ago (or that’s how it feels) that of course that’s the reason why the Masons aren’t Town confirmed, seems so obvious now I’ve said it. Last Mafia has to be Scunny or Adz from my point of view.
Vote Adz I don't want Adz in the game late on, his play has not been pro town and he's one of 4 players who I think could still be scum.
I think we lynch through Adz and then scunny if needed. Worst case they are somehow both town and it leaves us with 6 left if scum get 2 NK's done.
I feel like I’ve played quite a good town game to be honest. Even from D1 and the TLC wagon, highlighting its collapse etc. But I appreciate I can’t prove my role and therefore should be suspected.
In the end we have one thing not adding up. The night 3 Someone kills and SME poisoning. Burg's role states two things. First mafia get one factional kill per night Second he enabled a day chat Richards role states two things Mafia get one kill His role gets two shot cannot prevent kill TLCS role states Mafia get one kill "Once per night you can choose to poison somebody. A poisoned player will die after the next night. This will count as the current nights faction kill" The kills so far have been rather obvious targets. Mafia start off with no kill Hastag dies then later on so Mr burns get him. Jason looks like a cop. he dies at night. (night 2) Mr sheen looks a vital role he dies at night (night 3) how? Sme looks a potential danger to the bad guys as buss driver (has to be poisoned n3.. he dies at end of day 4 Theres no kill on night 4. (cannot be poisoning now?) Josh is an obvious known role target to get rid of as he can stop a kill. If the mafia has another power as speculated to do something then they must have been doing this overnight every night as well as kills? If they were taking out the obvious targets and leaving the more easily led/less active players alone then does it not also stand to reason that a redirector power will have messed up some other actions?
The Sheen N3 death has been discussed at length so far this morning. if you (or anyone) have any ideas then you are more than welcome to post them. Pointing it out again is not going to solve anything.
